Wednesday, February 29, 2012

Role of School Staff in Abuse Cases


            Continuing to explore the realm of our education system in New York, I decided to discuss the unfortunate events of sexual abuse that have been occurring in our schools. I began my research looking at the accounts that have already been made to known to us. From there, another article about another 30 year old school aide who abused fourth grade girls has emerged and one more from Darryl Lynch who was arrested for touching a 14 year old girl as well. According to the Wall Street Journal, the 30yr old, Brett Picou, was “the fifth school employee accused of sexually abusing children in recent weeks.”
            In the same incident, one of the victims said, "I'm a little girl, you are not supposed to do that to me," and in reply Picou said “"Oh, it's like that," and did not apologize.” In this particular case, Picou was not found to ever have had any previous physical or sexual cases or crimes against him in his file. So in this case, Chancellor Dennis Walcott’s vow to investigate any and all substantiated cases of misconduct dating to 2000 would not help since this just seems like a freak accident where a new offender emerged. Thankfully a victim reported the incident to the principal and the police were notified.
            However, in another incident with another offender, Wilbert Cortez who abused 2 boys, I was appalled to learn that the notification process with police took even longer due to incompetency of other teachers. I read the entire investigation report written on the case and to my utter dismay, when one of the victims in this story informed another teacher that he was touched inappropriately by Cortez, “the teacher offered to sit down with the boy and Cortez to “straighten things out.” Not surprisingly, [the child] declined the solution and suggested that he stop attending Cortez’s class. However, [the teacher] said that the boy had to go to computer class.” Mind you, this all transpired after the 3RD incident between the same boy and Cortez.
The failure of this teacher to inform an official or an authority allowed for other abuses to be committed to other students. This to me was the most frustrating. As in a court case called Franklin v. Gwinnet County (1992) under teacher and student personal interactions, the ruling did include that damages may be recovered if “an official of the school district who at a minimum has the authority to institute corrective measures on the district’s behalf has actual notice of, and is deliberately indifferent to, the teacher’s misconduct.” http://www.cepi.vcu.edu/newsletter/2010-2011/2011-January-Teacher-Dismissal-For-Unprofessional-Conduct.html. However, no action was taken against the teacher whom the boy had tried to contact for help and instead suggested a measure that was further traumatizing to the victim.
The horrors that this student and others like him may have been subject to have the possibility of being prolonged due to incompetent teachers who do not report an incident once it happens and is not held accountable for the consequences when these events emerge. While Chancellor Walcott’s attempt to stop the abuses by terminating all the teachers who may have had substantiated cases of misconduct from the year 2000 may be helpful, it would not have helped in the case of Brett Picou or Wilbert Cortez.

No comments: